Dil Chahta Hai

DIL CHAHTA HAI (2001, d. Farhan Akhtar)

Dil Chahta Hai2001 was a big year for Hindi cinema. For the first time in over a decade, an Indian film had secured an increasingly-elusive acknowledgement at the Oscars in the form of a nomination in the ‘Best Foreign Feature’ category for Ashutosh Gowariker’s cricketing extravaganza Lagaan. In the same year, Santosh Sivan’s fictionalised account of the life of Asoka made tremendous waves at international film festivals and secured a worldwide distribution deal in the process. And while these two period epics had enough arthouse-esque elements to rise above the usual Bollywood fare and please the Western critics, 2001 also produced another stunning breakthrough film that not only was hip and modern while still being unashamedly filmi, but was also the best of the lot.

Dil Chahta Hai (’The Heart Desires’) is the story of Akash, Sameer and Siddarth - three inseparable college buddies with three distinct personalities. Akash (Aamir Khan), the wise-cracking slacker; happy to carry on with his two-week flings and to put off getting a job for as long as possible. Sameer (Saif Ali Khan), the dim-witted hopeless romantic; desperate to find love and settle down. And Sid (Akshaye Khanna), the misunderstood dreamer; a painter in love with a divorced mother battling a drink problem. All three graduates are entirely clueless where life will now lead them and as their lives take the next step towards an unsure future, so too does their friendship.

Writer/director Farhan Akhtar certainly broke the mould in terms of mainstream Bollywood filmmaking with this refreshingly contemporary, heart-warming film that is distinctly Hollywood in execution and Indian in spirit. His debut effort adapts the standard filmi conventions of musical interludes and family melodrama seamlessly to a Westernised narrative, eliminating just enough needless masala elements to please just about everybody. This truly is one Bollywood movie that can appeal to one and all with no cultural or stylistic stumbling blocks. Technically, ’DCH’ also just happens to be one of the most understatedly well-made and well-written Indian films ever produced. Direction, scripting, editing and cinematography are all first rate, while the performances from the three leads all deservedly went on to become award-winning. Viewing such a superlative piece of work like Dil Chahta Hai makes it all the more bewildering that Farhan Akhtar subsequently has since gone on to squander his reputation with two wholly uninspired and dull follow-ups; namely 2004’s dire war drama Lakshya (’Objective’) and 2006’s entirely pointless (but nonetheless box office-friendly) remake of the 1978 adventure classic Don. Topping ‘DCH’ will always be a difficult task, but these two didn’t even come close. Here’s hoping Ahktar manages to rediscover his filmmaking talents in the near future.


Cool dudes: Aamir Khan, Akshaye Khanna and Saif Ali Khan

Dil Chahta Hai is available as a bare-bones release on DVD from Elite Films in the Unites States. Picture and sound quality are both excellent, while the English subtitles are well-translated. Avoid the U.K. release from Spark Worldwide, which features an inferior print and numerous MPEG compression problems.

Posted by Stephen on January 14th, 2007

8 Comments »

1

January 14, 2007 @ 8:42 pm

Okay, while I am kinda mad at you for calling ‘Don’ (2006) ‘pointless’ (I found it not just an update, but a very different movie from the 1978 one), ‘uninspired’ (come on!! it’s so cool and stylish!!) and ‘dull’ (hello?? SRK all bad and sexy?? - but then again, that’s quite possibly not your cup of tea), I really enjoyed this review.

I am not as in love with DCH as everyone else seems to be, but I did enjoy it very much, and it did go in a fresh direction while remaning very ‘commercial’.

I am really liking your site, BTW - was led here by Carla. Thanks very much for all the DVD tips.

2
Stephen said

January 14, 2007 @ 11:21 pm

Thanks for the comments, Daddy’s Girl. :)

There’s definitely divided opinion on the new Don. I am actually a big SRK fan and I thought his performance was decent, but the film itself just did nothing for me sadly. Maybe the original ‘78 version with the Big B is so ingrained in me that I just couldn’t enjoy the remake properly. I’m planning a detailed review for its DVD release soon over at DVDTimes.co.uk, so hopefully I’ll enjoy a repeated viewing a little more.

Thumbs up also for your blog, by the way. Love all the screencaps. 8)

3

January 15, 2007 @ 4:46 pm

Ah I pretty much don’t like SRK but I loved the new Don (btw I think the old man is pretty much cack - I’m sorry, have to be honest) if it weren’t for its OST! P.S. U know anything about this new Don (3 disk) Steelbook release in India? and how it compares to the UK release?

4

January 15, 2007 @ 4:47 pm

Typo - I meant Old One (as in Old Don)

5
Beth said

January 15, 2007 @ 7:07 pm

I’m reminded by reading your piece that despite loving it thoroughly I haven’t watched Dil Chahta Hai in almost a year. It’s definitely time for a revisit - and now that I’ve seen a bunch more movies, I expect this to stand out even more. I saw this and Taal very early on in my Bollywood-watching and I have been completely in love with Akshaye Khanna ever since (and of course none of his other roles that I’ve seen have measured up…).

6
Nadeem Rasool said

January 22, 2007 @ 10:00 am

Hey Good review, just want to know, where did you get the Elite version of DCH. I have the spark version, and seen comparisons between them and the Elite, and the Elite version is soo much better. Please could someone provide a link to where you can get this version.

Many thanks

7
Stephen said

January 22, 2007 @ 10:17 pm

I got my copy from IndiaWeekly.com - they claim that they only stock the Spark version, but it’s actually only the Elite disc they sell. There’s also lots of copies available from international eBay sellers. I recommend the H2Bcom store - they’re very reliable.

8
Nadeem Rasool said

January 23, 2007 @ 4:39 pm

Hey Stephen, Many thanks, Yeah read that IndiaWeekly.com, stock the elite version, however a friend of mine purchase the dvd over there, and they sent him the spark version :(

Will check out H2Bcom store..

Many thanks for the help, and can’t wait to see more indian reviews :)

Comment RSS · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment

Login     Film Journal Home     Support Forums           Journal Rating: 4/5 (4)