jump to navigation

#94: The Black Dahlia (2006) August 23, 2007

Posted by badblokebob in : Drama, Thriller, 2000s, adaptations, 2 stars, true stories, 2007, Film Noir: Pre/Post/Neo/etc. , trackback

2006 | Brian De Palma | 116 mins | DVD | 15 / R

Noir-wannabe, adapted from the James Ellroy novel based on a real, unsolved case. That case is far from the focus here; from the start the apparently-central crime is anything but, meaning the biggest let-down is that events barely follows the eponymous story.

It’s one of many problems in a film that tries hard to be a proper noir but fails in almost every respect: performances (most of which wind up flat), corny dialogue, plot, pretty-but-vacant direction, and even voice-over narration. I haven’t read the novel, but apparently it’s a poor adaptation too. What you want is a ’40s-style thriller; what you get is a weak ’40s-set character drama.

2 out of 5


no comments yet - be the first?

Login     Film Journal Home     Support Forums           Journal Rating: 4/5 (9)